Sunday,
17 October 2021
Today
marks a hundred years since the birth of George Mackay Brown (1921 -
1996). To celebrate this momentous date I have written an essay about
what I consider to be Brown's most iconic, wide-ranging,
forward-looking and prophetic work.
George
Mackay Brown and His Vision of Greenvoe
Introduction
Frequently
referred to as the Orkney Bard, George Mackay Brown lived a life that was narrowly
defined, but his artistic vision transcended borders and time.
Leaving his home town of Stromness only rarely he possessed a
remarkable gift that allowed his imagination to harvest from the past
in order to seed the present. He captured in words, with enormous
grace and sensitivity, the traditions and significant themes of
ancient history and wrought them into poems and stories which feel at
once old, yet also uncannily relevant to a contemporary readership.
He reminds us of the importance of noting Nature's rhythms and how
they shape our lives. As Berthold Schoene writes in his study, The
Making of Orcadia: Narrative Identity in the Prose Work of George
Mackay Brown (Schoene, 1995 : 26):-
History
is not a dead deposit burdening or paralysing our contemporary
existence, rather, it is a meaning-productive process from which we
draw the energy and motivation we need to tackle the future.
Brown
knew intrinsically that as a poet and writer, practising at a time
when literature and the arts as a whole were undergoing massive
change, he had a duty to his readers, however reluctantly, to convey
in his work his awareness of standing on the cusp between two eras.
The Age of Enlightenment was still much more than merely a fading
shadow in the minds of writers and artists, but the desire to update
old ideas and to experiment with new ones was increasingly tempting.
Refusing to respect the excitement progress and modernity engendered
in his contemporaries would have meant being left behind in terms of
getting work published and gaining personal recognition. Brown was,
however, adamant that the present cannot be considered without
acknowledging the influences of the past.
In
An Orkney Tapestry (1969), an anthology of Brown's first prose
writings, he says, "contemporary Orkney, cut off from the story
of its past is meaningless" (Brown, 1973 : 19). While Brown's
poems and short stories hark back to the past and deal almost
exclusively with subjects inspired by the Norse sagas, Orkney's
history, traditions, landscape and elements of the supernatural, his
novels are more forward-looking in how they address issues that were,
in his era, both historic and contemporary. This is particularly true of his first novel, Greenvoe (1972) and it is this notion of
contemporary relevance that I wish to focus on in my essay.
Brown
wrote Greenvoe as a direct response to the threat of Uranium
mining in Orkney during the 1970s. It was a peril which brought
together the Orkney people as never before. As one body they stood up
against the powers of the energy companies and the UK Government who
wanted to dig up the land along the so-called 'Uranium corridor',
which stretched from Brown's birth-place, Stromness, to the cliffs of
Yesnaby, on the west coast of Mainland Orkney. It took almost a
decade of concerted effort on the part of Orcadians to avert the
danger that many said would have meant devastation for the Orkney
Islands. In 1980, the Prime Minister at the time, Margaret Thatcher,
personally visited Orkney to assure its residents that excavations
for Uranium would not go ahead.
Of
all his novels, Brown's first gathers together most perfectly in a
single narrative, the issues which were closest to his heart —
community, tradition, Nature's cycle, religion, memory, identity, the
past and the contemporary. It embraces, furthermore, elements of
mystery, the supernatural, the Gothic and the psychological. Greenvoe
takes the reader on a journey. Its multi-layered structure is
deceptively simple and deliberately misleading. The reader's first
impression is that of a charming tale about a community in which folk
are hard-working, honest and helpful to their neighbours. This
perception quickly takes on a Gothic perspective which becomes
progressively more dystopian in nature as Brown reveals the
circumstances, flaws, emotional burdens and secrets of each of his
characters. The reader comes to understand that Greenvoe is not the
cohesive community it might at first appear to be.
Brown
converted to Catholicism in 1961 and although he disliked being
referred to as a Catholic writer he nevertheless was preoccupied with
certain religious themes and tropes which he employed time and again
in his writings. Their repeated use are an indication of the
importance Brown gave to his faith. In Greenvoe evidence of this can
be seen in the author's use of biblical references which punctuate
the text. The most obvious of these is the ancient religious ritual,
known as the ‘Ceremony of the Master Horsemen’, which celebrates
the cycle of the agricultural year. A section of the ritual ends each
of the novel's six chapters and serves to move the story forward.
Greenvoe
has a timeless feel to it. It is the story of a small fishing and
farming community on the fictional island of Hellya which, in the
space of a week, is annihilated by the corporate greed of a bunch of
faceless bureaucrats who infiltrate the village of Greenvoe to head
the mysterious Operation Black Star. Although Brown does not specify
the precise era in which his novel is set, it carries an ambience
that suggests it could be the late 1940s or early 1950s, the period
immediately after the Second World War. At the school children are
made to recite a list of famous battles which ends with the Battle of
Stalingrad - 1943 (Brown, 2004 : 83), but there is no indication that
this date has any bearing on the novel's context beyond showing the
reader that it was a time when rote learning was common practice in
schools. Brown makes no mention of the War. Neither are there signs
of austerity or poverty. Quite the opposite, in fact. Greenvoe's
Laird and his family are clearly well-healed people and the village
shop appears to be well-stocked and frequented. Children are
well-fed, eating bread and jam on their way to school (Brown, 2004 :
4) and customers come to the shop to buy bacon (ibid : 3) and bread,
candles, paraffin, margarine and ball-point pens (ibid : 5).
Operation
Black Star
At
the heart of Greenvoe lies the ominous Operation Black Star. Brown
leaves its purpose open to the reader's speculation. In an essay,
entitled Oil and the Orcadians, penned shortly after his novel's
publication, Brown outlined its core idea (Brown, 1972 : 1):-
…..
the purpose of Operation Black Star was
left deliberately vague. It could be an early-warning system, or a
probe for uranium or oil.
Diggers
arrive on the island and a construction site is set up (Brown, 2004 :
203-5; 208-14). The disenfranchised villagers are powerless to stand
up to the intruders. Instead of gathering strength through the
garnering of support from their neighbours, Greenvoe's inhabitants
adopt a passive-aggressive stance in which they take self-protective
action, but do nothing to attempt to avert the threat to their island
and livelihoods. They simply hide themselves away in their homes, as
long as these remain standing. In acts of unconscious
self-preservation they build invisible walls around themselves, thus
separating their inner and private lives from the façade which they
present to their neighbours and the outside world. On the occasions
they do venture out they treat the people they meet with unaccustomed
wariness. Their attitude is that of a voiceless, disintegrating
community unconcerned about the wellbeing of others. As Brown
brilliantly puts it (Brown, 2004 : 210):-
.....
piecemeal the village died [and] Greenvoe
shrivelled in the radiance of Black Star.
It
is in this part of the narrative that Greenvoe takes on an overtly
psychological context. The bureaucrats running Operation Black Star
gradually and surreptitiously manipulate the folk of the island of
Hellya into a state of abject fear. The Scarf, a Marxist and
Greenvoe's self-appointed amateur social historian, tells of how he
has got himself a job as a clerk in the offices of Operation Black
Star. There he finds cabinets filled with files on almost all of
Greenvoe's inhabitants (Brown, 2004 : 211 - 213). The question of how
reliable a narrator The Scarf is cannot be ignored.
The
villagers' fear for their future and that of Greenvoe manifests
itself in several ways. Arguably, the least surprising are drink and
violence. Simon Mckee, the Minister, who believes he has kept his
alcoholism a secret thus far, throws caution to the wind when he
purchases several bottles of whisky at once at the hotel bar. He says
they are for others. His mother, for medicinal purposes (Brown, 2004
: 48-49), or the request of a friend in Australia who has heard about
the excellent quality of Orkney’s malt (ibid : 178). The community
has, of course, long been aware of its Minister's affliction, but out
of respect for his mother the villagers talk about it only amongst
themselves. Like many psychologically unstable people the Minister
believes he can juggle duty and addiction unnoticed by the community.
Since his mind is overloaded with all the internal conversations
which that entails he chooses to shut out the fact that his problem
is widely known.
Two
fishermen, Bert Kerston and Samuel Whaness have a quarrel. When
Kerston steals his catch Whaness is uncharacteristically provoked
into attacking the thief (Brown, 2004 : 104 - 105). Brown momentarily
plays devil's advocate when he depicts Whaness as the villain and
Kerston as the victim. Later, Whaness tries to seek revenge by making
for the dangerous cliffs of Red Head in bad weather when he thinks
Kerston is unlikely to do so (Brown, 2004 : 147). As he congratulates
himself on finding his creels well filled, however, his boat is
enveloped in fog and thrown about on heavy seas. Finally, Whaness'
boat, the Siloam, crashes against the cliffs and collapses on top of
him (ibid : 148 - 149).
Brown
tricks the reader into assuming that Whaness’ bid to avenge himself
has ended in his tragic death. Notice the symbolism and psychological
guile which the author employs here. He describes, in Bunyanesque
fashion, how Whaness wanders about beneath the waves, meeting God in
a land of beauty and seeing himself as a young man again (ibid : 184
- 192). Suddenly, Whaness comes across the wreck of Bert Kerston’s
boat and sees his body. In a startling reversal of the surreal and
the real the reader learns that while Whaness attempts to resuscitate
his enemy in the next world, Kerston is doing the same for him in the
present one (ibid : 192 - 193):-
‘So
you’re alive’, said Bert Kerston above him. ‘By God, Whaness,
you nearly had it today. The sea nearly got you. You’ll never be
closer.’
Brown
toys with the dual concepts of good versus evil and the notion that
harm does not always come to those who have inflicted it on others.
Instead, it befalls, more cruelly, those who are generally
law-abiding, but who transgress in one brief unconscious moment of
madness.
Some
Freudian theory is apt here. It could be said that through the threat
presented by Operation Black Star, and their fear of being made
homeless, Greenvoe's inhabitants become split personalities (Freud,
1920 : 277). They dread being judged for their alarm and so pretend
to be unconcerned by the Stranger who moves into the hotel ahead of
the arrival on the island of the team of construction workers (Brown,
2004 : 36). By the time work begins and the destruction of people's
homes takes place, terror has washed over the community and distrust
reigns. It is full-scale abjection. In her essay, Powers of Horror,
the Bulgarian-French philosopher and sociologist, Julia Kristeva
(b.1941), describes the phenomenon thus (1982 : 4):-
There
looms, within abjection, one of those violent, dark revolts of being,
directed against a threat that seems to emanate from an exorbitant
force, outside or inside, ejected beyond the scope of the possible,
the tolerable, the thinkable.
Ivan
Westray is Hellya's ferryman. He is a man with a huge ego and great
sexual appetite. Having wooed the island's school teacher, Miss
Margaret Inverary, for a period he asks her to give him a sign when
she is ready to consummate their relationship (Brown, 2004 : 15):-
‘Light
that green lamp and set it in your window upstairs at ten o’clock’,
said Ivan Westray. ‘Then I’ll know I can come.'
The
teacher continues to hold out to him and when he rebukes her for it
by telling her: 'that was the arrangement’ (ibid : 15), there is an
implied threat that if she takes much longer about it Westray will
take her against her will. It sets a portent of what he is capable of
as is seen later when he rapes the Laird’s granddaughter, Inga
Fortin-Bell (ibid : 198 - 199).
The
rape scene captures the deep psychological and Gothic unease that is
the invisible glue of Greenvoe’s plot. Just as Operation Black Star
is a metaphor for the disintegration of Hellya's community,
specifically, and society as whole, so too is the ferryman's
treatment of Inga. It depicts a scenario that is timeless. Human
behaviour at its most depraved is both ancient and contemporary. With
its intensely symbolic use of fog and ominous language Brown creates
an atmosphere that is in keeping with the darkest traditions of both
Gothic and psychological storytelling. When Westray collects Inga in
his boat following her visit to the lighthouse keeper, Donald McAra,
they become lost in fog. Inga tries to hide her fear by making light
of it, but in doing so she fuels the unease of the uncanny scene to
the point that it reads like a passage from a psychological thriller
(Brown, 2004 : 197):-
‘It’s
like a journey into the land of the dead’, said Inga lightly.
Westray
addresses the girl’s concerns as though voicing an unconscious
premonition that has wider implications than merely acknowledging the
dangerous situation in which they find themselves. Westray tells her
(ibid : 197):-
'…..
you can’t live forever. I would rather
die in the sea than in the eventide home.'
Then,
moments before Westray throws Inga down on the deck of his boat and
rapes her (ibid : 198 - 199), he speaks these particularly
spine-chilling words (ibid : 197):-
'The
fog ….. it twists everything. Sights, sounds, feelings.'
I
suggest that there is considerable overlap, or synergy, between the
Gothic and the psychological elements of Greenvoe. The scene
described above, in which Ivan Westray takes Inga Fortin-Bell out in
his boat with the intention of getting inside her knickers, whether
she consents or not, and his previous threat to Margaret Inverary,
not only show Westray's vile attitude towards vulnerable young women
in his community, it is also an example of both the Gothic and the
psychological aspects of the novel converging.
Operation
Black Star represents the most post-modern element of the novel,
symbolising all which George Mackay Brown perceived as evil about
progress, modernity and life in the second half of the twentieth
century. It embodies the fostering of a culture of fear, iniquitous
corruption and a total disregard for the value of human life. It is a
stark reminder of the atrocities (loss of life, mind, health, home,
belongings, identity) which so many thousands had suffered in the two
World Wars. Isobel Murray and Bob Tait, scholars in Modern Scottish
Literature, in their critical study of Greenvoe, go as far as
suggesting that the project represents the arrival of Satan in the
community who performs "a hideous death-dealing parody of the
liberating life-bringing Christ". They argue that (1984 : 149):-
Operation
Black Star is the personification of Evil since it is ‘so
anti-human' that it takes on the form of inanimate modern building
materials, especially the concrete which Mackay Brown so deplores.
(ref: Brown, 2004 : 238)
In
light of the Orwellian nature of Operation Black Star it is
surprising that Brown’s literary interests and influences are not
recorded as having included the works of George Orwell since Brown
must have been aware of his writings. The nameless silent Stranger,
whose signature in the hotel’s guest book is indecipherable, stays
in his room for almost the entire duration of his visit. He is
recorded only once venturing out for a brief early-evening stroll
around Greenvoe, making secretive notes at a time when most of its
residents are likely to be indoors having their tea and his walkabout
won't attract attention (Brown, 2004 : 203 - 205). The Stranger is
not merely a voiceless, but menacing presence in Brown’s novel, he
also encapsulates the concepts of authoritarianism and tyranny on the
grandest scale. Through the clandestine psychological manipulations
of folk and the brutal destruction of their village Operation Black
Star makes the poorest in the community even poorer, ultimately
destroying lives and livelihoods.
The
Psychology of Symbolism
A
further psychological element of Greenvoe is that Brown endows each
of his main characters with a symbolic role that goes beyond merely
being a member of a small fictional community. The author depicts
their functions in such a subtle way that they do not jar or disrupt
the storytelling. The most obvious example of this literary device is
Alice Voar, the mother of seven children, each the offspring of a
different father. Voar is the old Norse word for ‘spring’,
traditionally known as ’seed-time’. Brown’s choice of
nomenclature for Alice, therefore, is a reference to her promiscuity
which reflects an instability of character, manifesting itself in a
readiness to yield to several sexual partners. In terms of Freudian
psychology it could be said that by giving in to those men and to her
desires her conscious mind was taken over by her unconscious. In
biblical terms, she easily submitted to physical temptation. The
resulting children are, hence, symbolic of both good and evil. They
are, on the one hand, a blessing, whilst on the other, Alice is being
punished when the relationship with their respective fathers does not
last.
Brown
carefully weighs up the number of characters in his novel who are
extremely devout and conscientiously practice their faith (fisherman
Sam Whaness and his wife Rachel, and Mrs. Elizabeth McKee, the mother
of Greenvoe's Minister), against those who indulge in what the Church
regards as immoral practices (fisherman Bert Kerston neglecting his
pregnant wife, Ellen, and the ferryman Ivan Westray’s raping of
Inga Fortin-Bell). In order to portray the psychological imbalances
of those within his fictional community and the fact that, as in real
life, things are not always what they seem, Brown goes on to examine
the consciences of the characters who, on the surface live ‘good’
lives, unsullied by sin, but who actually practice alternative
lifestyles or engage in activities which are less than honest (the
Minister, Simon McKee, attempting to disguise his drinking problem
and Bert Kerston selling his catch of lobsters on the Scottish
mainland, not to provide for his family, but to fund his own penchant
for beer and whisky). The misdemeanours of these individuals appear
relatively insignificant outside the characters’ own circumstances
and family circle. Collectively, however, their untruths are
indicative of the slow collapse of the community in which they live.
The
Reborn and the Martyr
The
most perturbing instance of the internalising of fear felt in
Greenvoe's community is that of the Minister's mother, Mrs. Mckee.
Prey to bouts of mental anguish and melancholia, she spends hours at
a time mulling over past events in her life. So intensely does she
engage herself in the activity that she is practically reliving them,
even recalling conversations word for word. Brown presents these
musings as extended stream-of-consciousness writing. By his own
admission he felt a close bond with Mrs. McKee, seeing her as the
most ‘assertive’ character in the novel. In his autobiography,
For the Islands I Sing, published posthumously, Brown says (1997 :
174):-
Mrs.
McKee, whom I grew to love more and more as the novel unfolded, led
me gently into her past life ….. she led me into places of the mind
I knew a little about, those places of guilt, prosecution, judgement,
which, while they last, make life bitter and terrible.
Occasionally
Mrs. McKee appears to fictionalise events in her head, either
partially, or in their entirety, such as when she recalls family
occasions when her son, Simon, was still a young lad. One particular
episode begins with her imagining herself as a member of the Scottish
Royal Court (Brown, 2004 : 106):-
It
was the ecclesiastical division of the court Mrs. McKee decided at
once. She had the feeling of Sabbath peace and gravestones; she could
almost hear the rustling of bands and black gowns.
During
her reflections Mrs. McKee steps out of herself, back into another
era. She is barely conscious that her fantasies are taking her away
from the present. Time and reality blur (ibid : 106):-.
Indeed,
she felt rather important, sitting in her rocking-chair with the blue
velvet cushion at her back. Fancy clever people going to all that
trouble on her account. She felt – Oh, gracious! – like one of
the handmaidens of Mary Queen of Scots, beautiful and fated, while
the speech lasted.
Brown’s
use of long paragraphs suggests a growing loss of control. Mrs. McKee
is mourning a past which, in the glow of happy reminiscences, feels
safe and unthreatening – a time when everyone in the community
worked hard and got on well together. In a Freudian context her
melancholia could be said to be a grieving for an ideal which has
been lost to her (Freud, 2006[a] : 310).
Mrs.
McKee’s symptoms – losing track of connections, misremembering
the sequence of events, recalling memories in isolation – are, as
Freud suggests in his essay Remembering, Repeating and Working
Through (Freud, 2006[b] : 393), a typical manifestation of the mental
processing of life experiences. Rowena and Brian Murray, in their
critique of Brown’s works, Interrogation of Silence, note that
(Murray & Murray, 2004 : 134):-
Mrs
McKee’s physical decline is paralleled by her psychological
deterioration, which in turn parallels the decline of the village and
the relationships between the villagers. All experience a form of
‘trial’ appropriate to their perceived failings.
After
a spell in hospital during which Mrs. McKee is unconscious and
delirious by turns she unexpectedly makes a nigh complete recovery.
This is how Brown describes it (Brown, 2004 : 219):-
She
knew at once where she was, from the sound on the stone outside. She
was in her own city, Edinburgh. It was a beautiful day in spring; she
knew it was spring from the slant of light on her face. Among
Edinburgh silences, birds sang in the trees. All her senses were
quickened.
Elizabeth
Mckee's mental distress and miraculous recovery is not hers alone. It
is yet another instance in which Brown employs its dark connotations
as a literary device to symbolise the anguish and fragility of the
entire island of Hellya, followed by its resurrection with which the
author ends his novel.
Perhaps
the most tragic character in the novel is The Skarf who spends entire
evenings in the hotel bar reading his manuscript, describing Hellya's
past, to his fellow drinkers (Brown, 2004 : 18-21). I suggest that in
creating him Brown is examining his own personality. His choice to
include the definitive article in the curious name implies that he
sees the character as the embodiment of a set of traits and beliefs
borne within the community in which The Skarf lives, rather than
being a breathing, thinking individual of flesh and blood in his own
right. The inference is that The Skarf carries the moral and ethical
weight of the people of Hellya on his shoulders. He is, so to speak,
the martyr of the story. In the Northern Isles 'skarf' is the local
word for cormorant, a bird which feeds on fish. Fish, in turn, are
full of biblical symbolism. The irony is that The Skarf has a dislike
for fishing, although he has a boat which he has christened the
Engels after the German-English socialist and philosopher, Friedrich
Engels (1820 - 1895), who in 1948, together with Karl Marx (1818 -
1883), wrote the Communist Manifesto.
As
a historian and Marxist, The Skarf has multiple contradictory
personalities. They reveal themselves through his opposing interests.
The historian in him wishes to preserve and record the past, while
the Marxist part of him desires historical and social change. Brown
presents, here, an unconscious struggle for supremacy between The
Skarf's supposedly innocent hobby of writing Greenvoe’s social
history, on the one hand, and his Marxist interests, which might be
deemed inappropriate in a small remote island community, on the
other.
The
Skarf’s narrative plays a dual function. Whilst looking back at
Hellya’s legacy it also foreshadows calamity. In describing the
natural, cyclical way in which life and nature moved in the past, he
implies that these things will not last for ever. The Skarf’s
knowledge and work symbolise a Foucaultian awareness of power and
social control (Foucault, 2002 : 44). His sources, research methods
and associations are never mentioned, but it would be unsurprising if
some readers don't wonder whether The Skarf is somehow involved in
Operation Black Star, particularly as he is the only member of the
community who finds employment in their offices.
Timothy
Baker, in his monograph, George Mackay Brown and
the Philosophy of Community (2009),
explains the psychological enigma of The Skarf’s work thus (Baker,
2009 : 36):-
The
Skarf’s writings encapsulates all the violence of the past, but
cannot stand against the violence of modernity itself; what is
written can be destroyed. In Greenvoe the forces of modernity
underwrite all that has been written, and in doing so prove the
inefficacy of the written word.
When
The Skarf reads his manuscript he does so in a soft, persuasive voice
close to Brown’s own style of speaking and writing. Like Brown, The
Skarf feels at once imprisoned by his way of life and his community
but is, at the same time somewhat lost and rudderless. He oscillates
between doing what is expected of him — daily going out fishing to
make a living — and searching for something to satisfy his own
ambition as an aspiring social historian. An example of this
conundrum is his conversation with Olive Evie, the shopkeeper in the
village store, which takes place near the beginning of the novel
(Brown, 2004 : 4 - 5):-
‘You’re
not at the fishing today, I see’ said Mrs. Olive Evie.
'That
was the worst thing you ever did, Skarf, going to work with your
uncle at the lobsters. You with all that brains. You should have gone
on to school,then the university.'
The
Skarf responds (ibid : 5):-
‘The
Lord works in a mysterious way, his wonders to perform.’
His
reply reflects a sense of hopelessness as well as suggesting an
unconscious faith in redemption; a feeling that it is only a matter
of time before he finds his proper calling. It is a personal journey
that he shares with Greenvoe’s author. Brown's opportunity for
escaping his own frustrations of living in a cloistered, insular
environment — Stromness in the 1940s and 1950s — were his
sojourns to study in Edinburgh. Furthermore, his conversion to
Catholicism released him from the dogma of his Calvinistic upbringing
which he had so resented. His new faith provided him with the
‘grounding’ and sense of direction which, until then, he had been
lacking.
For
The Skarf the outcome is rather more tragic. When his employment file
reveals his Marxist interests he finds himself quickly and
unceremoniously dismissed from his job at the offices of Operation
Black Star. Returning home to discover his house has been turned to
rubble in his absence, he walks to the beach, fills his pockets with
stones, unties his boat and starts rowing (Brown, 2004 : 222 - 223).
The
Skarf and Mrs. McKee are motivated by similar desires. Both are
"concerned with constructing an answerable history", as
Timothy Baker puts it (2009 : 50). While Mrs. McKee’s is a personal
one, The Skarf narrates on behalf of the community in order to help
it remember its heritage. For him, the exercise has not only a
historical purpose, but also a political one. I would argue, however,
that neither character is a reliable narrator since their rhetoric is
coloured by their own individually distorted perspectives.
Death
and Rebirth of a Community
The
final chapter of Greenvoe reads like part of a Cold War novel. The
names of those heading Operation Black Star are never revealed and
the secrecy surrounding their identities and the real purpose of
Operation Black Star creates a dramatic, angry tension not seen
elsewhere in Brown’s work. The description of unaccustomed sounds
and heightened activity is at once a depiction of the apocalyptic
events taking place on the island as well as a
foreshadowing of the effects of industrialisation and urbanisation
which will, in time, invade even the smallest corner of the Earth.
Brown writes (Brown, 2004 : 208):-
The
island began to be full of noises — a roar and a clangour.
It
could be said that Greenvoe's community is being possessed by the
'authorities', as its inhabitants refer to the faceless bureaucrats
on the rare occasions they find themselves being forced to interact
with them (Brown, 2004 : 209). They are no longer able to think
clearly and freely in order to make sense of what is going on, nor
are they able to take a stand against the destruction taking place.
As
they watch their homes, and then the hotel, being bulldozed to the
ground, the villagers undergo Freudian personality changes which
mirror Greenvoe's demise. Those who have relations on the Scottish
mainland flee the island or travel to Hrossey (the Norse name for the
Orkney Mainland). In other words, Brown plays with the notion that
Hellya is part of a larger archipelago. Alison Voar, whose sister and
only relative refuses to help her, is forced to take her children
into the hills above Hamnavoe (the Norse name for Stromness) where
they find accommodation in an old army hut from the Second World War
(Brown, 2004 : 211).
Poor
Mrs. McKee is only vaguely aware of occurrences outside her front
door during episodes of sleep, fitful dreams and states of
half-consciousness. Later, as she is lying in hospital in Edinburgh,
her only visitor is her son, Simon (ibid : 220 - 221). But while she
is still in a state of delirium before making her uncanny recovery,
it is unclear whether it is Simon in the flesh or merely the wishful
thinking of her fevered imagination.
Just
as the reader reconciles himself to the novel's dark conclusion,
Brown springs a surprise. He brings back seven of his characters who
had left Greenvoe a decade earlier after the dramatic events of
Operation Black Star. All, but one had been children when their
families were forced to leave Hellya. Amongst them is Mansie
Anderson. He plays only a small, but important role in the novel.
When faced with eviction he shows tremendous tenacity trying to save
his family's home, thus symbolising the archetypal Orcadian with his
spirited determination (Brown, 2004 : 234).
Now
an old man, Anderson represents the penultimate biblical reference in
the book in the form of Noah returning to the Ark. After the seven
men enact the final stage in the ancient ‘Ceremony of Master
Horsemen’, Anderson leads the dedication in which the men bid the
proper goodbye to the island which they were denied ten years
earlier. When the other men, in their roles as 'Master Horsemen',
believe they hear the word Resurrection in the sound of dust being
whipped up by the wind, they see it as a sign of hope and a portent
that there will be a future for Greenvoe and for Hellya after all
(Brown, 2004 : 242). The last line of the novel makes this indeed a
possibility. Its final sentence is also the final biblical allusion
(ibid : 243):-
The
sun rose. The stones were warm. They broke the bread.
Conclusion
There
are several reasons why George Mackay Brown's novel is not kailyard
fiction. Firstly, it does not discuss the culture, politics or social
issues of the day. Besides the ambience Brown creates in his
narrative, suggesting the 1940s or 1950s, the period in which
Greenvoe is set is deliberately vague.This enables the novel to
transcend historical epochs and to make it at once ancient and
contemporary. Secondly, although the novel is clearly about a small
rural community there is nothing nostalgic or stereotypical about the
story being told or the characters which inhabit it. Thirdly, there
is no evidence of an overly obsessive preoccupation with either piety
or poverty. Mrs. McKee is the only character whose religious
conviction is taken to extremes. In her case, the fragility of her
mental state is a mitigating circumstance. Her son, the Minister, has
little obvious passion for his office (Brown, 2004 : 178) and, as
noted earlier, the village shop, as the hub for gossip and the
women's reflections on their neighbours (ibid : 3 & 4), gives the
impression of being well-stocked.
Interestingly,
nowhere in his fiction does George Mackay Brown document either a
singular unified community, nor a world made up solely of individuals
living their lives quietly without significant external influences.
Instead, Brown focuses on tensions between characters and the
community or environment in which they find themselves.
The
final stage of 'The Master Horsemen Ceremony' is the first and only
occasion in Greenvoe where there is a sense of unity between the
characters. The seven men who return to Hellya after a ten-year
absence are united in their desire for redemption. Each man playing
his part in the concluding cycle of the ritual is a
'working-together' to bring about the rebirth of a community and land
that had been lost to them. In doing so they are displaying not only
a sense of nostalgia for a bygone era, but also a desire for a future
in an age in which progress and modernity promise personal growth and
fulfillment as well as a more cohesive island community.
In
his study, Pedagogy of the Oppressed
(1996), the Brazilian educator and philosopher Paulo Freire
(1921–1997) talks about what happens when a community is invaded by
external forces. When a new physical presence is established the
social order of the community is disrupted, he writes. Its collective
worldview is destroyed and that of the infiltrators becomes the
dominant one. Effectively, "the natural order of things which
previously existed within the community is annihilated" (Freire,
1996 : 134).
I
think George Mackay Brown would have appreciated the ideas expressed
by the German philosopher, Hans-Georg Gadamer (1900 - 2002), for whom
the past and present were a dialogue:-
The
present is only ever understandable through the past, with which it
forms a living continuity; and the past is always grasped from our
own partial viewpoint within the present.
(Gadamer, 2004 : 83)
About
art he wrote:-
We
enter the alien world of the artefact, but at the same time gather it
into our own realm, reaching a more complete understanding of
ourselves. Rather than 'leaving home', we 'come home'. (ibid
: 22 & 23)
Brown's
novel, Greenvoe is all of these things. It is art, because fiction is
an aesthetic creation. In its celebration of an ancient religious
ritual it is a glance back to the past and tradition. Through
Operation Black Star, with its implied corporate greed that is
willing to sacrifice the lives and livelihoods of an entire community
in order to accrue wealth and fame, it is an astute vision of the
present. Most significantly, perhaps, it is a declaration that the
human behaviour depicted in Greenvoe is innate to our species and
never wavers regardless of which period of history is placed under
the spotlight.
________________________________________________________
NOTES
Baker,
T.C. (2009) George Mackay Brown and the
Philosophy of Community. Edinburgh:
Edinburgh University Press
Brown,
G.M. (1973) An Orkney Tapestry.
London: Quartet Books Limited
Brown,
G.M. (1997) For the Islands I Sing.
London: John Murray (Publishers)
Brown,
G.M. (2004) Greenvoe.
Edinburgh: Polygon
Brown,
G.M. (1972) Oil and the Orcadians.
Orkney Library & Archive: Undated essay (ts) filed in the George
Mackay Brown Collection under ref. D124/2/4/29
Foucault,
M. (ed. McHoul, A. & Grace, W.) (2002) A
Foucault Primer: Discourse, power and the subject.
London: Taylor & Francis e-Library edition (a division of
Routledge)
Freud,
S. (2006[a]) ‘Mourning and Melancholia’ in The
Penguin Freud Reader. London: Penguin
Modern Classics
Freud,
S. (2006[b]) ‘Remembering, Repeating and Working Through’ in The
Penguin Freud Reader. London: Penguin
Modern Classics
Freire,
P. (1996) Pedagogy of the Oppressed,
London: Penguin Books
Gadamer,
H.G. (tr. Weinsheimer, J. & Marshall, D.G.) (1960) [1975, 1989,
2004] Truth and Method.
London & New York: Continuum Publishing Group
Kristeva,
J. (tr. Roudiez, L.S.) (1991) Strangers to
Ourselves. New York: Columbia University
Press
Murray,
I. & Tait, B. (1984) ‘Greenvoe’ in Ten
Modern Scottish Novels. Aberdeen, UK:
Aberdeen University Press
Murray,
R.&B. (2004) Interrogation of Silence.
London: John Murray (Publishers)
Schoene,
B. (1995) The Making of Orcadia: Narrative
Identity in The Prose Work of George Mackay Brown.
Frankfurt-am-Main, Germany: Peter Lang Gmbh,Internationaler Verlag
der Wissenschaften (Anglo-American Studies Series, Vol.6)
________________________________________________________